Jaymay, 'Autumn Fallin''

New York anti-folkie offers a warm vibe and smart lyrics on buzzworthy debut

By Adam McKibbin

Special to Metromix
March 10, 2008

Critic's Rating:
3 1/2

Jaymay, 'Autumn Fallin''
Autumn Fallin'
Release date:
March 11, 2008
Artist/Band name:
Jaymay
Record label:
Blue Note
Official Web Site:
http://jaymaymusic.com/
Overall User Rating:
0 (0 ratings)
Write a review
Backstory: Jamie Kristine Seerman was so nervous at her first open mic that she decided she needed a better performer name to help her cope. She dubbed herself “Jaymay” and became a regular—then a standout—in the New York City “anti-folk” scene that helped incubate Regina Spektor, the Moldy Peaches and Ani DiFranco.

Why you should care: Despite its narrative arc—a romance declining during a New York winter—“Autumn Fallin’” feels like a springtime album. It’s warm, accessible and likely to appeal to fans of Feist and Norah Jones, as well as to anyone who likes Regina Spektor’s voice but thinks she’s a little too weird.

Verdict: Charming if a tad precious, “Autumn Fallin’” should soundtrack many a romance (and breakup) in 2008. The melodies are simple but infectious, peaking with the stately “Blue Skies” and “Ill Willed Person.” Adventure isn’t her forte; the old-timey “Hard To Say” features some unfortunate scatting and underscores the creative gulf between Jaymay and edgier artists like Spektor. Jaymay’s best calling card may be her lyrics sheet--something she seems to acknowledge herself when she sings, “I’m winnin’ you with words because I have no other way.”

X-Factor:
Jaymay’s soft spot for storytelling spans a planned career in publishing (indefinitely postponed), a teenage addiction to Bob Dylan, and cutting her own creative teeth on self-described “stupid songs” about the family dog.

More CD reviews

More CD reviews

Because there's too damn much music to keep track of on your own.